A National Park Service employee walked out of his Skagway office and resigned Wednesday morning citing inadequate precautions for keeping park staff from being exposed to coronavirus. In an email to the Klondike Gold Rush National Historical Park superintendent, Dustin Stone warned his departure would be followed by others if things didn’t change.
“I can’t sit idle anymore. You know? It’s too important. Hours matter right now,” he said.
The Klondike Gold Rush National Historical Park buildings are closed to visitors. But Stone said his superintendent does not have the green light from senior National Park Service officials to give his employees administrative leave to stay home.
In light of close working proximity and the high transmissibility of the coronavirus, Stone said that is unacceptable.
He said other federal park service employees voiced concerns in a meeting this week.
“Because Skagway is such a small community, and we’ve all seen the flu rip through and affect half of the town over the course of a few days,” said Stone.
Skagway is an isolated town of about 1,000 year-round residents. The local clinic only has one ventilator (it is trying to acquire more). That gives it the capacity to treat two people who are critically ill with coronavirus. As of Wednesday, the clinic has sent two swabs to a lab for coronavirus testing; there are no confirmed positive cases.
A park service spokesman in Anchorage says that Klondike Gold Rush National Historical Park is following federal guidelines. Peter Christian wrote in a short statement that the national park will limit the number of summer staff hired to work in Skagway but referred most questions to its headquarters in Washington D.C.
Stone said that isn’t enough. He criticized the park service’s slow response. During last year’s federal government shutdown, park employees were sent home since they couldn’t be paid until Congress and President Trump broke the impasse.
“But during a time of national pandemic we are spending time sitting around and debating and arguing and hemming and hawing about what’s right. When the right thing to do is send your employees home, close your parks and, and figure out what comes next,” he said.
Stone is an elected member of Skagway’s municipal assembly. He and his wife run a bed and breakfast in town that they’ve temporarily closed due to the pandemic.
And Stone isn’t the only dissatisfied federal employee. The head of the federal Office of Personnel Management, Director Dale Cabaniss, resigned Tuesday night. Her office manages human resources for civilian government workers. The resignation signals increasing uncertainty for the federal workforce across the country.
This isn’t news, this is some kids personal problems with a convenient excuse in the form of global pandemic. This isn’t whistleblowing because the NPS is doing exactly what they’ve been told to do. This IS a waste of time when some real and pertinent information could be relayed or broadcast. I, for one, would LOVE to be earning money at a job that isn’t tied to the tourist industry, so maybe I can take your place?
You working right now Mary?
Shut up mary
Hi Mary.
I’m the guy in the article. You have just illustrated my frustration perfectly. The superintendents and park level employees are not to blame in this. They are trying to do what is right, but superintendents’ hands are being tied by politically motivated directives coming from the Secretary of the Interior and the highest levels of DOI and NPS leadership.
The official word from NPS is that all superintendents have autonomous control over their parks, but there are currently supers all over the US shouting that the NPS will not let them close gates in the face of a global pandemic that requires us all to step out of the way so it can pass more quickly.
I believe the DOI intends to throw superintendents under the bus when the finger is pointed at the NPS for a slow, negligent response to a public health crisis. Why else would they tell the media supers have absolute power, then send communications to those same supers limiting those powers?
I saw a problem I thought had the potential to affect my community and, because it is a service-wide problem (thousand of visitors streaming through park gates in the lower 48 everyday and thousands of employees interacting and working to support those parks), I decided to speak up as loudly as I could, and that necessitated walking away.
KHNS was the first outlet to listen, and their coverage has since helped me reach some national outlets to help elevate the conversation to a national level.
I hope this provides a little more context, and I am sorry if you still believe it is an incorrect response. I known it everyone agrees with me, but I can only follow my own moral compass.
For what it’s worth, you can absolutely have my job. I’m sure the park is hiring a new HR person and, it’s usually a pretty amazing place to work.
I’m 35 and it was my first time out of the service industry. Only lasted 7 months, but it was a nice break. Before that I worked at the liquor store, drove a bus and tended bar… I feel your tourism industry job pain and will be back in the pit with you as soon as the ships come back.
Please stay well and take good care of yourself and those around you in this uncertain time.
*not everyone agrees with me
If I’m understanding it correctly, Ms. Mary is basically saying that the guy in the article, Dustin, has some problems with where he works and is using the COVID-19 pandemic as an excuse to push his agenda and that it’s not news worthy.
If I’m understanding it correctly, Ms. Mary is basically saying that the guy in the article, Dustin, has some problems with where he works and is using the COVID-19 pandemic as an excuse to push his agenda and that it’s not news worthy.
Okay this website is messed up. Can’t reply to Joe and it just keeps replying to myself.
Darmetrius out.
< This isn’t news, this is some kids personal problems with a convenient excuse in the form of global pandemic.
not a native speaker, someone care to explain this sentence to me? i dont understand it.
Omg people for god sake!get over yourselves. It’s not about you or your park job or this site it’s about a very socially inept president who cant spell, or even read a teleprompter correctly giving the american public “fake news” trump should’ve taken covid more seriously wed all have our seasonal jobs then . Blah blah blah socially isolate please ! Just so the rest of us dont have to read your idiotic fodder
Of course it is our President’s fault. What isn’t right? Seems he was called ever negative name in the book when he closed travel from China to keep us safe. How’s it feel from the cheap seats? May you, your family, and friends stay safe and healthy. Stop politicizing this please.
YEP! Some kid quits a great federal job with a great retirement because??? The Grand Canyon was endangering people because someone might get the flu bug there? Because Yellowstone is too small and was making people cluster together??? L.M.A.O. Give me a break…some kid who has a personal problem with a supervisor and is too silly or foolish to work around it decides he can wrap himself in the cloak of self-righteousness and claim “I quit for my ‘Merica!” LOL, TOO funny.
The govt KNOWS people will not stay home. As great as it sounds on paper, the public NEEDS a place to go when all the kids are off school and the house gets boring. It was FANTASTIC thinking of Trump to keep the parks open and waive the entrance fees. GREAT IDEA!! What better place to allow social distancing than the 1,218,375 acres of land at the Grand Canyon National Park or the 2,219,789 acres of land at Yellowstone National Park!!
Now I know this makes poor Dustin the Righteous work harder and he’s mad about that, so he quit. I’m sure he’s enjoying his 15 minutes of fame and he will be signing autographs at McDonald’s in Needles, California by next week (but only during his breaks lol). His fake niceness will soon fade when he’s working for 8 bucks an hour with no benefits because of his choice to resign from a federal job with full benefits and retirement….because his opinion was more important than ensuring Americans had a safe place to go during the shutdown. They could go to the mall, and most likely would, but the parks are open and are free. Thank God. Even if Dustin doesn’t get it. A federal career thrown away for a week or two of interwebs popularity over the flu bug this year. Hilarious stuff…even more so to see him posting about how “the conversation is being elevated to a national level”. Stop and think about that for a sec…..and you’ll see how that and the fake niceness is about as empty as his office is at the Alaska state park. 😉
https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/flk5ra/i_am_dustin_stone_i_walked_out_of_my_job_at_the/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf
https://slate.com/technology/2020/03/national-parks-are-staying-open-is-that-safe.html
https://www.outsideonline.com/2410554/us-national-parks-covid-19
https://www.9news.com/mobile/article/news/health/coronavirus/estes-park-mayor-pleads-with-feds-to-close-rocky-mountain-national-park-during-pandemic/73-1a8dfa53-a564-4320-85ec-19581fa9d088?fbclid=IwAR3ScOx0Wx-NPH5PFPJHf7XwiERxgMnAOtxRn3a5He8Ra23ZS1u8TccUvDM
https://www.google.com/amp/s/api.nationalgeographic.com/distribution/public/amp/travel/2020/03/national-parks-waived-fees-coronavirus-health-risk-remains
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.mercurynews.com/2020/03/20/national-parks-are-free-but-some-oppose-that-amid-the-virus/amp/
https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.rgj.com/amp/2878927001
https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/environment/2020/mar/17/national-parks-cause-public-health-concern-visitors-flood-in
Maybe have an idea what you’re talking about before you open your mouth. You don’t seem the type, but heres some light reading anyway.
Hi MURphy,
I’m not sure why my decision has you so upset, as I’m guessing you know nothing about me but, if I can, I would like to provide you with some context.
I chose to leave because I saw my employer, the National Park Service, behaving in a way that threatens national health, and the safety of at-risk individuals in my town.
Parks are not all wilderness areas, and in parks with wilderness areas, most visitors are not in the backcountry. People congregate I popular spots for photos, etc. Your joke about the Grand Canyon is a good example. There was a picture posted to a comment on the NPS Facebook page for this week of a large crowd of visitors huddled together along a road and Grand Canyon National Park.
I spent the last several days talking to NPS employees around the US who are seeing the same thing, everyday. Some parks are even seeing increased crowds following the announcement that fees are waved.
Towns and municipalities surrounding parks are also affected and many, like Moab, Utah are actively working to request that parks close, and are taking steps to limit their impact by passing legislation temporarily banning the operations of hotels, closing services, etc.
Parks also require employees, working together, to operate. These employees also interact with visitors. Independence hall, also a National Park Unit, has had visitors into the hundreds at a time this week, all interacting with interpretive staff, who in turn interact with other employees, members of the public, friends, families and service workers. At a time where the White House and CDC are requesting we do the exact opposite of this, it is negligent.
You referred to COVID-19 as the flu, but the flu has a .01 mortality rate versus a roughly .10 mortality rate for COVID. It doesn’t seem like much but, assuming an equal rate of infection, if the flu were to cause 100,000 deaths in a year, the COVID number would be 1,000,000.
The real danger of COVID-19 is not the mortality rate, as we have many viruses with much higher rates. It is the high rate of transmission. COVID-19 spreads at a pace that, if not slowed by social-distancing and self-isolation practices early on, can quickly reach exponential growth.
Our current growth rate has outpaced that of Italy, which is experiencing a full blown collapse of their medical infrastructure due to a lack of hospital beds and ventilators, necessary to treat critical cases.
Here are some US confirmed case stats:
Jan 1: 1 case
March 8: roughly 500
March 16: 4,632
March 17: 6,421
March 19: 13,677
March 21: 19,624
If we continue increasing at an exponential, or near exponential rate, it is not long before the number of cases will exceed our capacity to treat them. The US has the capability of treating 1 million patients, and the CDC predicts 214 millions cases in just over a year. The worst case scenario death toll, should we continue on this path is in the neighborhood of 1.7 million Americans.
The trickle down of this is, it also greatly limits the ability to receive treatment for any other medical issue when all staff and beds are monopolized by a flood of COVID-19 patients.
Skagway, has one ventilator and no doctor. That give us the ability to treat 2 cases before our system is overwhelmed. We have a significant at risk population: the elderly, type-1 diabetics, people with reduced immune systems due to cancer treatment, etc.
Our valley is narrow and most of us live in an. area of 22 blocks by 4 blocks. In flu season, when one of us gets sick, most of us get sick.
From the outside, we may appear insulated from the virus, but there are currently seasonal employees arriving in town via ferry and bush plane, from Juneau. They come from all over the country, and world, and all of them pass through Seattle, which is experiencing a large-scale infection. It will be here soon enough, or could potentially be here already in asymptomatic individuals.
The best chance we have to prevent a mini-epidemic, is to slow down the rate of transmission, thereby spreading the number of infections out over a longer period of time, following White House and CDC guidance that says to practice social-distancing, and avoid non-essential work interactions when possible.
When my coworkers and I asked why we were still being required to work in an office, one where the leadership team continued to meet and sit in a conference room that did not allow for proper social-distancing, the response was that the NPS did not think it was necessary to do anything more than put out hand sanitizer and disinfectant spray. The most recent science indicates that COVID-19 persists in the air for hours and on plastic surfaces for up to 3 days. We all use the copier, doorknobs, staplers, etc. Given the unique risk our town has for infection, this guidance seemed foolhardy and unsafe for Skagway.
Add to that the fact that the park was still debating the number of seasonal workers we were planning to bring into a town with an active state of emergency declared, which requests employers do the opposite, and maybe you can start to see my frustration. The NPS is failing with its response nationally, and also locally here in Skagway.
Moving on, I don’t find it likely that I will be at a McDonalds in Needles anytime soon. I am not stupid and I am not a child. I am a 35 year old with a degree and enough in savings to be fine until I decide what to do next. The purchase of the business my wife and I were working on will be delayed, as it is also currently closed due to this pandemic, but we understand we are still in a good place while many in our town are facing a much more uncertain economic future.
Skagway is my home and has been for 8 years. I am a member of the assembly, sit on the KHNS board of directors and am actively involved in this community. I did not act for internet fame, I acted out of concern for my community and for national health. This also benefits Skagway as, the longer we continue to ignore CDC guidance nationally, the longer before our cruise ships, 95% of the economy here, will be able to return.
This is not political. President Trump has recommended we all practice social-distancing and self-isolation as well. These are facts. I understand that we live in a post-fact society, where people can choose the media outlet that suits their own personal bias, but this is not the time to spread misinformation.
You are grossly misinformed. Your ignorance is dangerous and your callousness toward your fellow human beings is absolutely worthy of disdain. If you are unable to add anything to this conversation, other than Fox News talking points and flaccid insults, I politely request that you see yourself out. The adults are talking sweetie.
The niceness is not fake. I am a genuinely friendly human being, and I believe my entire community can attest to that. But, in a time where facts, common-sense, selflessness and empathy are of critical importance, I see no need to waste my time being friendly with someone wallowing in indifference and willful ignorance. I doubt anything I have written here will actually make it through to you, but hopefully someone more capable of rational thought will find it useful.
With all that in mind, I honestly wish you and your loved ones the best of luck in the not-too-distant future. It is not the end of the world, not even close, but this has already been paradigm shifting and we are only just getting started. My sincere hope is that there are less individuals who think like you out there so we won’t have to endure the effects of this longer than necessary.